NY Pizza Suprema

Ahmet Basci 3 months ago

Best pizza in midtown hands down! Plain slice is delicious. Great crisp but still has some chew and has a tangy sauce which is amazing. Burrata slice is very good. Great flavor combo White slice w/ garlic is amazing. Huge dollops of ricotta and fantastic garlic flavor. Service is awesome; everyone is very friendly and welcoming. 100% recommend if you have a day planned in midtown

Kevin Drost 3 months ago

NY Pizza Suprema is a true NYC classic that has been serving pizza since 1964. They offer around 25 different kinds of pies, including vegan options, so there’s something for everyone. The slices have a perfectly thin, foldable crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Just make sure you know what slice you want before you get to the counter because this place gets busy and they’ll have you ordering quickly. Located right across from Penn Station, it’s one of the best spots to grab an authentic New York slice. 🍕

Pape Diop 5 months ago

This is the standard of a perfect NY CHEESE pizza slice and I’ve eaten here about 10 times before I felt comfortable saying a statement so bold. For sure the best slice I’ve had in the city and any slice I have after will be compared to this. I’ll update accordingly if I ever find a better place. The pizza sauce is the highlight of the show. On top of the fact that the crust is sturdy and crispy, they also perfected the sauce to cheese ratio in every way possible. It’s so flavorful with a hint of basil that takes it to another level. I’m ashamed to admit the name kept me away from here for a while. Anything “Suprema” I’ve had in the past was genuinely mid or below par. This place was the perfect way to tell me never to judge a book by its cover.

T Rank 5 months ago

NY Pizza Suprema right outside Madison Square Garden is an absolute go-to spot if you’re looking to grab a slice (or a few) at any time of day. I had a layover at the train station nearby and knew I had to take advantage of being in NYC to get some quality pizza- and this place delivered. At first, the slices might seem a little pricey, but once you see the size, it makes total sense. They’re huge, filling, and packed with flavor, making it well worth the cost. The pizza itself was exactly what you want- classic, delicious New York-style slices done right. What really stood out though was the staff. Everyone was super friendly and welcoming, and you could tell they genuinely care about the customers. While I was sitting there, I noticed two young girls who were deaf, and the staff went out of their way to make sure they got their order correctly. Instead of just calling out slices, they personally brought the food over to them. It was a small moment, but it said a lot about the kind of place this is and the people working there. Overall, NY Pizza Suprema is more than just great pizza- it’s a spot with great people and a welcoming environment. Definitely a must-visit if you’re n

Deavon Lynch 6 months ago

This is my second time here. I came from Costa Rica and had to come back to this place again. I stayed in NYC for two days and ended up eating here about 15 slices—no joke. The pizza is amazing, the prices are perfect, and the experience feels real. What I love most is that it’s full of locals, not tourists. If you want authentic New York pizza, this is the spot.